Question

Ok, I TOTALLY love peanut butter with apples! But the PB is high in points, what’s a good substitute? I have PB2 but I don’t know what to mix it with. HELP

Answer 1

I just sprinkle it right on my apples!  

Answer 2

Fat free cool whip!  

Answer 3

There is no substitute for peanutbutter. You learn to measure it. ‍♀️

Answer 4

That is one of my most favorite snacks also! I use Jif Whipped. It’s less in points than regular PB.  

Comments

@tetrabasic i love that too

Answer 5

I use powered PB

Answer 6

I just use water

Answer 7

I mix one Tbsp of PB with Greek yogurt for 3 points and it gives me the PB satisfaction with way more to dip from!  

Comments

@aston856 good idea

Answer 8

Pb 2 works for me. I make it with 2 tablespoons of PB 2 and 1 tablespoon of water mix and enjoy

Answer 9

Mix it with sugar free maple syrup. It’s soo good!  

Comments

Makes all the difference!  

---

@jaret I’ll have totRy that!  

Answer 10

I just mix it with water

Answer 11

I just mix mine with water. Everyone has their own preferences, but I like it that way.  

Answer 12

PB2 and a little Honey

Answer 13

I mix it with sugar free pancake syrup, this is so good with apples

Answer 14

Jiff Whip love it

Answer 15

Walden farms zero points have the whole jar!  

Answer 16

I spend my points on peanut butter because I LOVE peanut butter and apples also!  

Answer 17

Water to the same as PB

Answer 18

Jif whips is delicious. I just use teaspoons instead of tablespoons. I would never use the artificial stuff.  

Answer 19

Don't put a lot of PB on your apple slices It taste the same with a little or a lot

Answer 20

Try All American Butter peanut butter. It’s delicious! Worth the points. Higher protein, lower carb peanut butter that will fill you up. SO GOOD!  

Answer 21

I dip the apples straight onto the PB2 or sprinkle it on the apple. You dont have to mix with anything.  

Answer 22

Mix it with bananas or triple zero yogurt

Answer 23

I take the hit on points with peanut butter. There is no good substitute for it. I use jiff whips.  

Answer 24

Mix with SF Syrup.  

Answer 25

I have mixed the PB2 with fat free half and half using my immersion blender. Store left over in fridge.  

Comments

@streamway good idea

Answer 26

Tjs chocolate humus

Answer 27

Smuckers natural peanut butter

Answer 28

If you have the Jif To Go peanut butter it’s 8 pts. Plan your day around it. Fish/chicken and veggies for dinner = 0.  

Answer 29

Better than Peanut Butter is good

Answer 30

PB2 is only 1 point per 2 tablespoons which will make a lot of peanut butter. Do you have Pb fit? It’s more points.  

Answer 31

I just mix 2 Tbs of Pb2 with water. Slice the apple & dip in Pb. So good

Answer 32

I mix my PB 2 with sugar free maple syrup. Super yummy!  

Answer 33

Mix the pb2 with water or a skinny syrup.  

Answer 34

I find the pb2 taste better mixed with warm water

Answer 35

I use water and 2 packets of splenda

Answer 36

I mix JIF Peanut Powder with 1 T of real (Smuckers Natural) peanut butter. I add 1 packet of Splenda Natural. Makes 2 servings, 3 points - for a lot of “peanut butter. ”

Comments

@industrialize Haliniewski I’ve never seen jif peanut powder. Where’d you get it

Answer 37

PB2 and just water is delicious but you can add cinnamon for an added yum  

Answer 38

What is PB2

Comments

@mezuzah21 powdered peanut butter

---

@mezuzah21 it’s a powder protein source: peanut butter or chocolate peanut butter Seriously Delicious in smoothie with unsweetened almond milk, banana or apple and ice Filling and lasts as it’s protein! I have one for any meal sometimes or just cuz I’m hungry

---

@silsby Lynne Thomas sounds good

---

@waylan never heard of it.  

---

Amazon, BJs I’ve gotten either place btw

---

@silsby Lynne Thomas lm in Canada

---

@mezuzah21 Costco has it

Answer 39

I use protein /almond milk. I don’t like it with just water.  

Comments

@mollee do u think it would taste good with regular milk? I dont like it with water either but never thought of milk.  

---

@aphrodite65 yes! My daughter actually used regular milk first and I thought of the protein milk later. I could not succeed without PB2

---

@mollee ill definitely be trying it today!  

Answer 40

A little SF chocolate syrup and a little whip. Delicious!  

Answer 41

Pb2 wit cinnamon. Bit of water. Great on apples

Answer 42

Equal parts water! Delicious

Answer 43

PB2 and sugar free pancake syrup and a little water

Answer 44

Greek yogurt

Answer 45

I mix pb powder with sf coolwhip

Answer 46

I don’t mix it with anything. I just slice the apple & sprinkle the pb2 on the slices. It’s super good that way

Comments

@laura same

Answer 47

I think you're supposed to use water

Answer 48

Chop an apple, sprinkle on cinnamon, a little PB2, pour SF maple syrup over and microwave 2-3 minutes for a warm, yummy snack.  

Comments

@disassociate can l use regular pb

---

I haven't tried that. I can't keep real (! ) PB in the house because of the high points and I'd eat it all!  

---

@mezuzah21 sure you can, just track the points

---

YES! I don't want fake PB lol

Answer 49

Not a substitute for PB but chocolate hummus is good with apples.  

Comments

My problem was I ate the whole dang container of chocolate hummus in one sitting. it was so good! So now I am not allowed to buy it anymore. no control.  

Answer 50

1 Tbsp is 3 points on green. I use the real stuff. There are some things I won’t substitute and pb is one of them.  

Comments

@waikiki76 not bad 3 points for tablespoon and I won’t substitute either!  

---

@waikiki76 2 T is 1 pt on green

Answer 51

I love it mixed with premier protein drink caramel and then use it as coffee creamer. So god!  

Comments

@cobb30791 I never tried that

Answer 52

Water as per instructions on the package

Answer 53

Jiff whips

Answer 54

I eat reduced fat jif and only eat half or quarter the serving size perfect with apples. I eat that for a snack too

Answer 55

Just water. I like to make it fairly thin so I can sort of coat the apple slices.  

Answer 56

I tske my PB2 and use my sugar free Italian sweet cream creamer to mix it. I sometime add a pinch of stevia and some cinnamon.  

Comments

@bula99 that sounds delicious. Thanks for sharing. I will definitely have to try this.  

---

@bula99 gotta try that!  

---

Girl that sounds yummy‼️ I need to try this!  

Answer 57

This is pretty good on apples and half the points as PB.  

Comments

@diu2136 yes! Thank you

---

@diu2136 another good idea - I LOVE all the great tips!  

Answer 58

Whipped peanut butter!  

Answer 59

Mix PB2 with water

Answer 60

Better'n Peanut Butter from Amazon 1pt per Tablespoon

Comments

@clackmannan never heard of that. What is it, why lower points and what does it taste like. Sorry just love peanut Butter so much. Lol

---

I have been a peanut bitter lover for about 70 yrs. and have found it to be the best substitute yet. You keep it refrigerated and I used it everyday.  

Answer 61

What is pb2

Comments

Powdered pb you mix with water

Answer 62

Greek yogurt

Answer 63

I eat an apple with PB2 almost every day

Answer 64

PB2 adds water

Answer 65

I have found if I microwave my real Peanut butter it drizzles over the apples for better coverage.  

Comments

@pregnant I do this. it's amazing how a little bit will drizzle to cover so much!  

Answer 66

I put 2tbsp pb2, 1 tsp stevia and a little salt in a dish, mix it up and drop in an cut up apple, stir. Yummy

Answer 67

I use the Dannon Light & Fit and use either the salted caramel or sometimes the caramel apple pie flavor. 2 points for whole container. It is so delicious with a cut up apple! :)

Comments

I dip the apple slices in it like its PB lol

---

@ritenuto great idea!  

Answer 68

If you do a tablespoon of regular peanut butter, it's only 3 points. Microwave it and it triples. Cut up your apple slices, drizzle over top. I've actually gone down to half a tablespoon for 2 pts.  

Answer 69

I mix it with cool whip and use it as a dip

Answer 70

You mix with water, its good in plain Greek yogurt or in a protein shake

Answer 71

PB2 Madagascar vanilla, 2T, mixed with 1. 5T sugar free maple flavored syrup, a little cinnamon. Mix together. Yummy on apples!  

Answer 72

Forgot to say my PB2 recipe above is One smartpoint.  

Answer 73

Microwave one T peanut butter, mix with my above recipe and mix well. The total is then four points. Eat whatever portion you can afford in points!  

Answer 74

PB2 just made per the instructions but I prefer using Jiff whips, 5 pts for 2 Tablespoons but I just use 1 tablespoon.  

Answer 75

I am with you love peanut butter too many points  

Answer 76

Don’t like PB2 made with water!  

Comments

@asterism I add a tiny bit of sweetener and salt and water. It’s really good that way.  

---

Mix with sugar-free Hungry Jack maple Syrup. game changer

---

@elope interesting

---

@kresic2138 it actually taste more like peanut butter then when mixed with water

---

@elope I don’t like the water and pb2 taste. I will have to try the syrup

Answer 77

Try Pb 2 , Madagascar vanilla, mixed with 1T light OJ

Answer 78

I use sugar free syrup to mix it and a tiny bit of water. I love it

Answer 79

It's a good peanut butter substitute but don't expected it to tastes exactly like pb. Theres no fat in pb2. That being said I've come to love pb2 because it satisfies my taste for peanut butter. ❗

Answer 80

I just dip apples in the PB2 powder. use less and get a strong pnut butter flavor and only 1 point!  

Answer 81

I mix PB2 with a combination of sugar free maple syrup and water.  

Comments

@floatation Houchin that looks yummt

Answer 82

Ww recipe chocolate water pb2 folded into ff whipped cream sliced bananas.  

Answer 83

I just learned not to love peanut butter. Sad but true!  

Answer 84

PB2 mixed with vanilla yogurt is to die for

Answer 85

Use Regular peanut butter ! 2 TBLS HAVE 6 points . smash it with a banana and dip an Apple into it. Lots of good for you stuff in there. That will hold you until around 1 or 2. Eat off the Zero point list for lunch and you have it made.  

Answer 86

Sugar free or fat free cool whip mixed with PB2. Yummy

Comments

@daphnedaphnis Sheldon Sounds delicious. Do you mix it with water first or just add the powder to the cool whip?  

---

@ritenuto Sweeney mix with a little water. I sometimes add a tsp of regular pb too.  

Answer 87

PB2 and SF syrup. Sounds wonderful. Definitely going to try even tho I love it even with water

Comments

@acre468 Baird Amazing with the SF syrup!  

Answer 88

I use jif whipped

Answer 89

Add a little to Greek yogurt O percent fat

Comments

@pena I did but it was a big blob

Answer 90

I mix it with water. A pinch of truvia and salt. Peanut butter has salt and sugar in it. It tastes awesome. Love it.  

Answer 91

Better’N Peanut Butter. 3 pts for 2tbls

Answer 92

Just cut to 1 tb.  

Answer 93

I dip apple in Sabra Hummus! Yum!  

Answer 94

Try sugar free PB. Not as good as Jiff but not bad. Low in points high in protein

Answer 95

Haven't tried peanut butter with apple. isn't it weird?  

Comments

No, it'soooooooooooooo good

---

Hmmmm curious here. leme try it sometime

---

@yaupon8353 let us know how you like it

---

Ok will do. I just dunno when because I am now imprisoned. at home LOL

---

I struggle with subbing PB but did find that the powdered PB is pretty good mixed with yogurt. Jiff whips is MAYBE one point lower than others.  

---

Hehehe you really love PB eh?  

---

@yaupon8353 OMG, Apples & Peanut butter is delicious! I agree with Bethany, you haveeeee to try it.  

Answer 96

I LOVE PB too. I’ve not found a good replacement! It’s worth the points for me . I have PB and banana most days !  

Answer 97

I cut up a granny smith apple and just dip it in pb2 in powder form. Yum!  

Answer 98

PB2 with that nonfat greek vanilla yogurt ( I use the light and fit) since I only use 1 tblsp of it. its only 3sp and it took care of my craving for real Peanut butter and apples. probably my new favorite snack

Answer 99

I don’t like the grainy taste of PB. Any tips?  

Comments

Mix with warm water.  

Answer 100

Mix it with sugar free maple syrup.  

Answer 101

I just mix water with my PB2. Love it with apples

Answer 102

Hint: put a little regular stevia in it. I use maple, or ? .  

Answer 103

Yes it is. Also cheese & apples.  

Answer 104

The Peter Pan whipped is good. Spreads smoothly so goes a long way and you use less