I think I'd be tempted to do the personal loan, because it frees up a big chunk of change. BUT, knowing myself, I would pay that off and then not really use it to continue paying off debt. So, I think I would do Belk and Capitol 1, then throw the rest at the next highest interest rate and snowball from there. Save the personal loan for last. I don't know the details, but there can't be too many months left on it anyway!