Question

Has anyone stayed in a hotel in key west that they loved? I am not looking to do airbnb because it will only be for a night or 2. Online there’s a ton of great options, just curious for some personal recommendations. thanks!  

Answer 1

Loved Pier House. Has its own beach and close to everything!  

Comments

Also stayed at Southermost Beach Resort but liked Pier House better. Have fun!  

---

@shona thank you!  

---

@shona we have stayed at both of those. I agree, pier house hands down.  

Answer 2

There was one we looked into before the oil spill 10 years ago. let me see what it is.  

Answer 3

We loved Waldorf Astoria, Casa Marina. A lot of hotels don’t have a beach but they do.  

Comments

@tillotson we just stayed there in February and really liked it!  

Answer 4

We stayed at Margaritaville. We enjoyed it.  

Comments

If you are going for a special event I highly recommend Latitudes on sunset key. The ferry is right there at margaritaville.  

---

@czar thank you!  

---

@czar absolutely agree! Latitudes is amazing!  

Answer 5

Duval House. It was amazing!  

Answer 6

Ocean Key

Answer 7

We loved our time spent at Margaritaville!  

Answer 8

Southernmost or the Hyatt Centric.  

Answer 9

We’ve stayed at the Sunset Key Cottages and Margaritaville (before it was margaritaville). Both were great! Location of Margaritaville was perfect for sunset and walking to the nightlife. Plus with the pier there lots of excursions take off. Only slight downside is that’s where cruises undock which can block the view but wasn’t a huge issue for us.  

Answer 10

Parrot Key! This is the same hotel the Real Housewives of O. C. stayed on one of their trips too  

Answer 11

Island city house! Great location, walkable to the water but off the main streets so relatively quiet at night.  

Answer 12

We love the Simonton Court (no kids allowed) and the Eden house. We go 3-4 times a year

Answer 13

We stayed at The Reach for our wedding! Own beach!  

Answer 14

Pier house for sure

Answer 15

Casa Marina

Answer 16

Pier House is great! And can’t beat the location!  

Answer 17

Loved the Parrot Key

Answer 18

Pier House great location on Duval!  

Answer 19

Westin! Right on the water and in the center of everything.  

Answer 20

Southernmost! Close enough to Duval & all the action but a bit off the beaten path so it’s quiet if you just want to lay by the pool or beach & relax. They also have free bikes, which are fun to use to get around (if you’re sober  ).  

Answer 21

Southernmost hotel for sure! We stayed there for our Honeymoon and it was spectacular!