I've been in your position. It's tough. You can do this! My first recommendation is to check your state's statute of limitations. My state is 5 (or maybe 7? ) years. So, basically if it has gone 5(or 7) years with no payment or contact at all, they cannot take you to court. Each state has different laws. Do your research. If it were me and there was a similar statute of limitations, I would work on the more recent accounts. (This doesn't apply to federal student loans. )