Auto insurance. I'm fresh from a divorce and have had car insurance in my name the last 6 months.Auto insurance. I'm fresh from a divorce and have had car insurance in my name the last 6 months. I'm currently with esurance *because they would insure me since I hadn't had insurance in my name for 10 years due to being married and listed as a driver on our policy* and I pay $110 per month. I got a quote from geico for $82 a month and progressive for $35 per month. These are huge differences in ranges all for same coverage. Any recommendations for either company? I've got a good driving record and I'm almost 51. I can start the new policy march 1.