+74 votes
by (1.8k points)
Alright, it's my birthday next week! What is a good substitute for birthday cake?! I'm trying really hard to be good  
Alright, it's my birthday next week!

63 Answers

+24 votes
by (53.1k points)
 
Best answer
Here is how I handle holidays. I figure there are about 20 food days a year. Holidays, birthdays, bbqs, etc. It is not those 20 days that get us into trouble. It is what we do with the other 345 days. At the beginning of the year I mark down 15 days where I plan on enjoying myself without guilt. I keep 5 aside for spontaneous celebrations. I know these days are coming so I can be super good on the days leading up to them and the days following. I expect a gain/maintain on my next weigh in but I am okay with that because it is temporary and I enjoyed myself. I also have learned that I can eat my Birthday cake guiltlessly, but I don't need to eat everyone's birthday cake. Unless they are part of my 20. For instance, I have cake on my husband's and my moms but not my siblings, niece, nephews, cousins, unless they are milestones. Then I might consider making it one of my 20. As much as I love my work family, I don't use my 20 on work celebrations. My 20 day system works well for me because it make it easier for me to stay on track when I know one of those days is just around the corner. It works for me. Also just so you know. Those holiday candies are the same candy you avoid all year long they are just in fancy magical holiday colored tinfoil. Remember that!  
by (430 points)
I love that, thanks for sharing!  
+31 votes
by (5.4k points)
It’s my birthday next week too! I am having a lower calorie version of banana cream pie! Happy Birthday!  
by (5.4k points)
@zakarias Thanks gorgeous!  
+30 votes
by (6.4k points)
If you have a sugar free cake mix, you can mix it with 1C of nonfat Greek yogurt and 1C of water or other sugar free liquid and it makes a delicious cake! Only 3 pts/slice on green for 12 servings
+35 votes
by (2.8k points)
It's my birthday soon too. But I'm going to live a little. And have what I want. Life is to short.  
+40 votes
by (730 points)
A cupcake
+18 votes
by (1.7k points)
Angel food cake mix.  
+35 votes
by (23.4k points)
I was just going to have some ice cream on my birthday; but I had a sirloin steak and that made me full! Didn't have the ice cream. But if I was still hungry I would have.  
+45 votes
by (8.8k points)
Angel food cake
+18 votes
by (1.2k points)
Fruit cake?!  
0 votes
by (2k points)
Fibre one birthday cake squares xx
+25 votes
by (1.2k points)
Angle food cake ! Add fruit on top. Or put pineapple and angel food cake mix. bake in glass dish. not sure on pt. With this new system
+10 votes
by (8.4k points)
Watermelon “cake”. Decorate with available fruit
+45 votes
by (16.9k points)
Fiber One Brownie, microwaved for 20 seconds.  
+22 votes
by (2.4k points)
Weight watchers cheesecake. I like it with fresh fruit. ( It tastes ok but not great without it). I'm referring to the nonfat Greek yogurt and jell-o cheesecake mix.  
+17 votes
by (7.3k points)
My bday was this past sunday, i didn't have anything extra for a cake or anything, but i did have an extra glass of wine!  
+19 votes
by (7.3k points)
A watermelon cake, but made by a special friend or family member. I tried to transfer the picture I had, but couldn’t figure how to do it.  
+41 votes
by (71.6k points)
My birthday was Friday and my husband's was Tuesday. We had Carvel Icecream cake because that's a delicious trackable choice.  
+41 votes
by (8.3k points)
Angel food and strawberries is my favorite
+13 votes
by (3.8k points)
Halo top birthday cake :)
+11 votes
by (25.5k points)
Birthday, Christmas, anniversary and Easter 4 days a year I just put in max pts for the day on something random and don’t count at all. Now there is no birthday week but one day doesn’t matter I have cake and pizza and all the things I want. Those 4 days didn’t make me fat lol
0 votes
by (930 points)
Gurrrrl, it's your birthday! Eat some damn cake!  
+49 votes
by (3.7k points)
On my bday I get 1 cupcake. I enjoy it. No leftovers
+26 votes
by (1.1k points)
My friend boiled herself an artichoke!  
+27 votes
by (6.3k points)
A Klondike bar sugar free is 8pts.  
+14 votes
by (6.5k points)
When my birthday comes, I plan on celebrating the day. WW is a lifestyle, not a diet. I will eat within reason, and feel darn good about it.  
by (2.9k points)
Same! That's the one day I don't track!  
+29 votes
by (2.1k points)
Eat the cake! Lol
+43 votes
by (700 points)
Angel food
+33 votes
by (8.9k points)
I say eat a piece of cake and count the points  
+44 votes
by (3.9k points)
Strawberries and whip cream. on a little angel food cake.  
+45 votes
by (1.6k points)
Jenna on Instagram has a delicious cake for 4 points per BIG slice! Super delicious and moist!  
by (1.6k points)
@undertenant I have personally made this and it’s so good! I am a very picky eater too, if it doesn’t taste close to the real thing I won’t eat it! This passes the test!  
0 votes
by (20.5k points)
Fiber One birthday cake bar, 2 points!  
by (1k points)
@omophagia so good
by (20.5k points)
@allisan2 I’ve ordered the lemon ones in my next grocery pickup, I heard they’re yummy too
+40 votes
by (5.3k points)
Maybe fruit with whipped cream? Add chocolate sauce?  
+13 votes
by (29.5k points)
Like ur thinking, Laura
+15 votes
by (55.1k points)
Strawberry short cake on angle food cake.  
+7 votes
by (850 points)
My go-to when my birthday comes around “One day of eating poorly will not make you fat, just like one day of eating healthy will not make you skinny”. Enjoy your birthday  
+20 votes
by (5.2k points)
A sugar free cake mix can of diet soda bake as directed top with fat free coolwhip
+8 votes
by (8.3k points)
Skinny Cow SF Ice Cream Sandwich with SF Chocolate Syrup and cool Whip.  
+38 votes
by (1.2k points)
Best wishes
+40 votes
by (880 points)
For my birthday I enjoyed chocolate pizzells with Reese's peanut butter cup dairy whipped topping.  
+21 votes
by (1.8k points)
Angel cake with light whip cream and decorated with strawberries and blueberries!  
by (6.4k points)
+32 votes
by (2.6k points)
Who says you need cake? My favorite sweet treat right now is Greek nonfat vanilla yogurt and either strawberries or blueberries and on the blue plan one cup of the yogurt is only four points.  
+35 votes
by (7.6k points)
The zero point cheesecake with berries and cool whip is fabulous
by (220 points)
@corrosive Newmeyer - The whaaaaaat?  
by (7.6k points)
@phonemic5068 just look on Pinterest zero point Cheesecake. I add way more trivia than the recipe calls for tho
+52 votes
by (3.8k points)
Katy, Happy early Birthday. My Birthday is on the 27th of @bemire34 and I plan on Angel Food cake with strawberries and whip cream.  
+34 votes
by (450 points)
I love the Smart bakery cupcakes 1 pt
+56 votes
by (1.8k points)
Just have a small piece and move on.  
+19 votes
by (2.2k points)
Mines next week too! I'm letting dinner and dessert be my present, ! One day will be ok!  
+8 votes
by (3.2k points)
Angel food.  
+61 votes
by (3.1k points)
Fruit salad
+61 votes
by (1.2k points)
You can make a cake. Just substitute a can of pumpkin for the eggs, water and oil. You won’t even taste the pumpkin
+36 votes
by (3.6k points)
Happy Birthday, Katy, and go buy yourself one piece of whatever you want, eat it, savor it, enjoy it, and track it. That’s reality and life. Go on the next day!  
+7 votes
by (6.3k points)
I still want my cake so we now just buy specialty cup cakes. It is a single serving. I do not count the points but It is for my birthday
+67 votes
by (760 points)
My birthday is next week as well. I am going to eat a piece of cake and be done.  
+70 votes
by (5.4k points)
Calories don’t count on your Birthday!  
+51 votes
by (24.5k points)
Banana split made with Greek yogurt instead of ice cream.  
+23 votes
by (29.5k points)
Angel food cake with strawberries and fat free reddi whip
+27 votes
by (1.3k points)
Cupcake! Portion controlled and you feel like you “had your cake and ate it too”I get all the other cupcakes out of the house bey giving them away!  
+50 votes
by (1.5k points)
Eat birthday cake, use weeklies to fit it in.  
+8 votes
by (7.3k points)
If you want the taste of birthday cake, but also want it portion controlled, look for Fiber One "birthday cake" bars. They are 70 calories - 2 pts.  
+1 vote
by (1.6k points)
Watermelon cake
by (20.5k points)
Oooo, I'd LOVE that!  
+18 votes
by (2k points)
See if you find a Carvel tht makes thinny thin low fat low calorie ice cream cake
+5 votes
by (2.3k points)
Lots of fun with your family. Do something special. Look through old photos. Maybe make an album. Hug your loved ones. Do some yoga. Play some happy music.  
+7 votes
by (9.3k points)
Booze  
+72 votes
by (6.6k points)
Eat the cake. Plan for it. Adjust the points youre eating during that day and the week (you have weekly points. They're your birthday gift. Happy birthday)
The Weight Watchers Group is where you can always find questions, answers, advice, reviews & recommendations from other community members about recipes, meal ideas, and tips for the Weight Watchers diet.
...