Question

I'm a newbie.  I love buttered rye toast, but 5pts for butter is a lot.I'm a newbie. I love buttered rye toast, but 5pts for butter is a lot. What's a good low point substitute? I googled and got applesauce, etc which is ok for baking but not when you want buttered toast.  

Answer 1

I found this on amazon, i love it , 0pt great on popcorn, toast, bagel, corn, veggies.  

Comments

@missing how much does it cost?  

---

@pappy i am in canada, it was 8. 76 no shipping cause i am a amazon prime member.  

Answer 2

Spray buttrr

Answer 3

Spray butter on toast and air popped popcorn!  

Answer 4

I love the I can't believe it's not butter light spread.  

Answer 5

Spread with sugar free jelly or mashed banana.  

Answer 6

Measure how much butter you really use! Teaspoon of REAL butter is worth the points!  

Answer 7

Homemade apple butter. Thin sliced swiss.  

Answer 8

Whipped butter, you can use more for less points

Answer 9

Whipped cream cheese is good

Answer 10

Spray butter

Answer 11

I love Parkay spray butter

Answer 12

I can’t believe it’s not butter light

Answer 13

I can’t believe it’s not butter light!  

Answer 14

I just started using I can’t believe it’s not butter spray. I was skeptical but it was good on popcorn so should be good on toast too.  

Answer 15

I use less butter

Answer 16

Anchor lighter spreadable x

Answer 17

Becel light 1 point for 2 tsp

Answer 18

Can’t believe it’s not butter spray-10 pumps is 0 points on Blue

Comments

@cockswain Yep!  

Answer 19

Land o Lakes whipped butter. 1 point for half a tablespoon.  

Answer 20

I agree that you can just use real butter but use less. 1 tsp if only 2 pts. As a lower point alternative spread, I like Land O’Lakes Light Butter Spread with Canola Oil

Answer 21

I can’t Believe Its Not Butter spray no points then use sugar free jelly

Answer 22

Country crock light

Answer 23

I really like this! It doesn't leave the bread wet like some other products do.  

Answer 24

Melt a tsp butter and dip toast in.  

Answer 25

I can’t believe it’s not butter

Answer 26

Landolakes light butter. Green label and only 2 points

Comments

@pleopod yes it has canola in it, very tasty

Answer 27

I don't like fake butter. I use Breakstone whipped butter on my toast, sparingly. I think it's 2 points for 1 tsp.  

Answer 28

Brummel and Brown

Answer 29

Whipped butter everything else tastes fake to me

Answer 30

I use spray butter.  

Answer 31

Can’t believe it’s not butter spray . Zero points

Answer 32

I really like whipped butter, I just use less. 1 tablespoon = 3 pts. I usually use about a teaspoon for a slice of toast.  

Answer 33

I use spray butter.  

Answer 34

I use hummus. Totally satisfied. Roasted Red pepper from Sabra. Don't miss butter at all!  

Answer 35

I use real kerrygold butter. A little goes a long way. It’s worth the few points

Answer 36

I use whipped light butter. It’s 1 point per teaspoon and I use it sparingly.  

Answer 37

I Can’t Believe It’s Butter Light

Answer 38

Spray butter. It doesn’t take much to give you the flavor.  

Answer 39

Spray butter

Answer 40

I use the land o lakes whipped butter. 1 pt 1/2 tbsp, 2 pt for 1 tbsp.  

Answer 41

Land O’Lakes Light butter with canola oil, 2 points for 1 tbsp.  

Comments

@singerice Riviere this is what I use and it’s amazing. I love it way more than the butter I used to buy!  

Answer 42

Brummel& Brown

Answer 43

Winona spray butter

Answer 44

I can't believe it's not butter light spread.  

Answer 45

Balade which is sold at Trader Joe’s.  

Answer 46

You can always use spray butter

Answer 47

I can’t believe it’s not butter has a spray butter with 0 calories and 0 fat

Answer 48

I love Brummell & Brown (yogurt butter)!  

Answer 49

That is 5 points for a Tablespoon. That is a lot of butter for one piece of toast.  

Answer 50

I use a tsp of Whipped lightly salted Breakstone’s. I buy seeded Rye bread at the bakery at my Publix supermarket and have them slice it thin. I figure it’s 1 to 1-1/2 points a slice unless large.