Girl. it took 11 years for me and my husband to get it together. We knew all the things we should be doing but couldn't string together enough successes to make it feel like progress so we would slowly slip back into our old ways. What I discovered, after many years of reflection, was that I was too controlling and not doing a good job of communicating with my husband, and he wasn't very good at holding me and himself accountable. Honestly, we just drew a line in the sand in 2014 and told ourselves that living for today was not helping us plan for tomorrow. We got focused, created a plan that was more than just a budget, and set some priorities - something to look forward to, right?! We cleared up $35k in debt in about a year, all while cash flowing his return to college, and closed all our credit cards once they were paid off. You say you do a budget but are compulsive spenders, so it really sounds like you put a plan on paper but aren't good at following through. Is that a fair statement?