+13 votes
by (490 points)
I am looking for automated shades that won’t break the bank. Any suggestions?  
I am looking for automated shades that won’t break the bank.

8 Answers

+2 votes
by (510 points)
 
Best answer
IKEA  
+2 votes
by (230 points)
I used somfy ones as ikea did not do the size I needed was cheaper for the blinds but the hub was expensive but got it now so blinds will be cheaper
+6 votes
by (860 points)
I just added iblinds to my existing blinds. The price tag still had me on the fence for a lot of months (until we started spending all our time at home and walking around to adjust blinds all the time got old fast) but it's cheaper than most integrated options.  
+7 votes
by (330 points)
Www. helloaxis. com - retrofit solution on your existing shades with a beaded chain or loop
by (720 points)
$229 is absurd for what these devices do. Especially when people have a bunch of windows to retrofit. Thats called "breaking the bank". Each window should be sub $100. One day someone will develop one to compete at a more appropriate price range.  
by (120 points)
My god these are a ripoff!  
0 votes
by (750 points)
Ikea fyrtur ❤
+2 votes
by (500 points)
The brunt blind engines are a really reliable option to automate existing blinds. I love mine for the time being. until the tech catches up and gives us something worth spending the money on
+8 votes
by (2.1k points)
The cheapest is diy. I'm working on converting mine automated open and close. Looking around $30-50 a blind depending on how much of a battery I use. Solar charged too
by (720 points)
@optative7488 this has been a dream of mine. I event bought stepper motors and boards and have a 3D printer for parts. but it never materialized (too many other projects). Would love to see what you put together. $30-$50/window is the “just right” price point.  
by (2.1k points)
@steadfast well for an overview: NodeMCU ESP8266 as the wifi and controller. Can push commands to it with webcore with it running a webserver. ~$5 a board. Cheap hobby servo with enough torque to turn the louvers ~$5 Bought a cheap phone power bank with a 21700 battery, 5000mah ~$12. Only worry is the battery isn't large enough. Found another charger for $16 with 2 for 10000mah. Going to test and if necessary run that. TP4056 lithium ion charger. This will charge the battery, protect from overcharge, and shut the battery off if it gets too low. ~$1 a board. 5. 5v solar panels got 5 of them will run in parallel for about 300ma of charge current. Will hook to the TP4056 to charge the battery during normal use. $8-9 Was going to use the circuit of the battery pack as a boost converter to get 5V out, but it seemed to stop working so I might have to pickup a cheap boost converter, which is probably a couple bucks too. My biggest cost is the battery, but if I can find cells for cheaper, i can save some there. May need a larger solar panel too. But that's going to take some experimentation to see what works. Luckily 99% of my windows see sun for at least half of the day. Would love to run power to the windows which would bring the cost down to about $10, but the wife doesn't want cable hider tracks on the walls, so I have to get creative!  
by (2.1k points)
Also I have been designing and printing a gearbox to fit in my blinds. About 3 iterations in and I just have to test now
by (720 points)
@optative7488 love it! I actually have plantation shutters so I think the servo/actuator might be more simple. I was also thinking a remote batter pack mounted on the other side of the shutters so it’s size was somewhat irrelevant. But yeah, running power would be better. We currently have powered window sensors for our alarm system and I was thinking of piggybacking off those somehow.  
by (2.1k points)
@steadfast thanks! Hopefully everything comes together. Unfortunately the ESP8266 runs at about 60ma with spikes up to 170ma. Which I estimate about 2. 5 days of use before the pack needs charged (5000ma). Which sucks honestly. I could maybe do a month before I need to touch it, but if it only lasts a week I'll need a better solution. I'm hoping I can keep it afloat with solar, but then again I may need a bigger panel. Just a matter of testing and tinkering until I find something that works. Or the wife breaks and I run cable hiders to the top
+8 votes
by (490 points)
I'm not into DIY and the IKEA don't have sizes that work for me. I reached out to Somfy to find a dealer near me. I should've mentioned I have bay-style (but not full-bay) windows here so sizes and a solution are tricky. I am willing to pay a premium if it's turnkey.  
The SmartThings Group is where you can always find questions, answers, advice, reviews & recommendations from other community members about home automation with the Samsung SmartThings hub.

Related questions

...