Question

Need suggestions for a good sugar free jelly. I crave PB Fit and jelly every morning. I tried Smuckers peach and strawberry. Both taste like the smell of crayons. Any suggestions? Thanks!  

Answer 1

Why do you need sugar free? if it's something you really enjoy then work it into your daily points. The only thing I do sugar free is soda, because I drink too much if it's not.  

Comments

@shuler222 I am diabetic.  

---

Oh ok, that makes sense then.  

Answer 2

Smuckers has a excellent less sugar (strawberry and grape) I use it all the time and I'm cautious with my points

Comments

I use this one also, very good and low points

---

@congius thanks. I will look for the less sugar instead of sugar free.  

---

@footstep you will definitely like it, amazing flavor!  

---

@angelitaangell probably, they have several

Answer 3

All fruit jelly

Answer 4

I like the Smuckers BlackBerry. It doesn't have that gross after taste.  

Answer 5

Just use fruit

Answer 6

Polnar all fruit

Answer 7

I've been eating Great Value (Walmart) sugar free blackberry. It's yummy.  

Comments

Never tried their brand. I think Smuckers is not as good as the others stated on here. I have to try Walmart's Thanks.  

Answer 8

I go for Smuckers LOW sugar. 10x better than the sugar free and the points aren’t too bad

Comments

I used to buy it but can't find it anymore. Where did you find the low sugar? Thank you.  

Answer 9

Polaner's sugar free strawberry preserves

Comments

I think they are the best. Smuckers leaves an aftertaste in my mouth.  

Answer 10

Make your own easily with chopped fruit, sweetner of choice and chia seeds to thicken. Lots of recipes. The chia seeds thicken the jam and give you extra protein and fibre ‍

Comments

@revel this is a great idea. Thank you. I made sugar free jelly a few years ago with special pectin, but it was more like glazed fruit.  

---

Does it count as points if you make them into jam? Like it does with smoothies?  

Answer 11

Polander all fruit

Answer 12

Polander's Sugar Free has a much better taste than Smuckers. I think. I had a light English Muffin today with liquid butter 0 Calories and this Polander's which I scanned and had 0 points. I got Shoprite Light English Muffins which are so much better than Thomas's they are only 2 points. So for my breakfast it was 2 points.  

Comments

Well no I had half a glass of the Tropicana 50 so 1. 5 pts. for that. Don't drink 8 ozs. I use half Cranberry Juice too Diet only 5 calories and mix that with it.  

Answer 13

I have substituted banana or apple slices instead of jelly. You could experiment with fruit you love  

Answer 14

I have about given up on finding anything low fat, low sugar, etc. that either tastes disgusting, or is flavorless. For me, it is better to eat half of the real thing!  

Answer 15

Make your own. Fruit of choice, splenda and water. Cook down. Add vanilla or almond extract if you want. Keeps for a month in the fridge.  

Comments

Cranberries are excellent this way with some orange juice and some zest.  

Answer 16

How about peanut butter? Is there a low sodium available?  

Answer 17

Polaner’s cherry

Answer 18

Sugar free Smuckers blackberry

Answer 19

Walmart brand blackberry. Snickers blackberry is also good.  

Answer 20

Orange marmalade