+4 votes
by (7.6k points)
I see a lot of people asking about net carbs and calories while in phase 1. I’m wondering what is everyone’s macro in the app if following the plan? I follow the plan and my carbs are between 40-50 net grams and at 30-40%. I thought following the plan we didn’t have to Worry about this but I am phasing off next week and wondering if this is why I fail everytime. First time I lost 40 pounds in 12 weeks and this time I lost 32 is 11 weeks
I see a lot of people asking about net carbs and calories while in phase 1.

3 Answers

0 votes
by (960 points)
For following P1 we don’t worry about the macros. The range you stated of 40 to 50 net in P1 was my range in P1, too. Why do you think this translates to P2/P3 failure? Have you tried 2020 P2/P3? It is tied to macros quite differently than the four phase program. (PS you can still keep it to 40 to 50 net but try it with your coach as written and see what happens and adjust based on what happens each week). Is there something more specific that leads back to a full P1 restart for you?  
by (7.6k points)
@husking so each time I have phased off over time I have gained the weight back plus a few pounds. This last time was well after a few months I started gaining. I’m hoping phasing off on the new program that I will have better results. As I was told to in the step down (old phase 3) I want to keep my macros at 40 but that’s not including the protein and veggies. My concern is if the veggies I’m eating which are from the sheet if they have too much carbs?  
by (960 points)
New P2 is one week step down (old P2) and 8 weeks depending on weight loss & your comfort with it) of stabilization. In terms of the veggies, the ones that “don’t count” are the occasional and select veggies that are the same as P1. If you want to keep that in check without having to keep track of just those net carbs, pick the unlimiteds and the select and keep your occasionals to 4 cups or less per week. Everything else vegetable/fruit/grains/potatoes/beans counts toward the net carb limit. So, 4 cups zucchini you don’t have to count. Technically, 2 cups of tomatoes you don’t have to count but if you think you are quite sensitive to the carbs sugar in them, then just keep them to up to 4 cups per week. Keep either a paper or IP app food diary so that you can see if those make an impact that you will have to track. Does that make sense? Limit Greek yogurt or cottage cheese to once a day then cut back if that becomes the problem. Some people are very carb sensitive and actually do need to count ALL the net carbs and limit them ALL to 40. Do you think you might be in that group? I am surprised that P2-stabilization works as written and works well for me—stunned, actually. (I’ll have my struggles when there is actually opportunity to eat at restaurants and more socialization opportunites that revolve around food or just eating stuff that other people cooked and figuring out how to count it. )
by (7.6k points)
@husking makes a lot of sense. The only thing is I only eat the select and unlimited veggies and stay away from the occasional ones. So if I stick to what I’m doing then I shouldn’t worry u less I see a high increase in weight. I know the first tome around I started gaining weight in phase 2. Praying this is not the case. I do know of the macros and increasing weekly until maintenance basically. If I recall I think I was told 4 weeks for how much I lost but will have to double check
by (960 points)
@emersonemery My coach has another dieter who gained dramatically on old P3(with the big breakfast and a different coach) who is doing great and happy with new p2/p3 so there is hope;) You should do great especially since you are paying attention. Select veggies at four cups a day should have minimal impact. You’ll do great and it’s ok to go up to eight weeks if you want or need to.  
+2 votes
by (2.8k points)
Try downloading the Carb Manager App. You can set your own macros and it helps to keep you accountable going forward. Try getting the macros from your coach. I didn’t have any luck with mine. She is new and not trained in macros. Please share them if you are able to get any help I’m scared to go into maintenance without this knowledge as well. I’ve fallen off the horse a few times in maintenance and I think this is why. Well. maybe it’s the beer ‍♀️
by (7.6k points)
@filature35 I believe the new program for step down is different for everyone one. I’ve lost 32 pounds in 11 weeks so I was told to keep Marcos at 40 and increase by 5 each week until I’m stable. But to follow for at least 4 weeks. I think it goes by how much weight u lost and how long on the program.  
+1 vote
by (6.3k points)
@emersonemery - watch ben bikman from low carb Denver on the Metabolic advantages of ketones and you’ll learn why calorie counting isn’t applicable and maybe a maintenance plan. I chose a ketogenic maintenance plan due to all the education.  
The Ideal Protein Protocol Group is where you can always find questions, answers, advice, reviews & recommendations from other community members about recipes, tips, and support for Phase 1 of the Ideal Protein Protocol.
...